If your child is making their First Holy Communion, you’ll want a cake that looks the part without the stress. And if you’re making it yourself, the good news is that these easy Communion cakes are completely achievable, even if you’ve never decorated a cake before.
Don’t miss our best content straight to your inbox! Sign up now and get our FREE newsletters packed with fun ideas and things to do with the kids, family-friendly recipes, expert advice, parenting tips and great competitions.
Communion cakes can end up looking like mini wedding cakes, with the price to match. A homemade cake is a great way to keep costs down on what can already be an expensive day, but that can feel daunting if you don’t think of yourself as a confident baker. Rest assured, we’ve pulled together simple, easy Communion cake ideas that are sure to impress your guests.
You May Also Enjoy 30 Reasons to Know You’re the Mum to a First Communion Child
Easy Communion Cakes to Make at Home
Simple Flowers
This cake shows just how effective simple decoration can be. It’s kept plain with white icing, then tiny flowers are used to outline a cross. The flowers are made with a flower plunger cutter (widely available online), or you could use sprinkles instead for the same effect. Use a toothpick to gently outline the cross first, then follow that line with your decorations.
You May Also Enjoy 10 Inspirational Ideas for Homemade First Communion Cakes
Communion Cupcakes
Image: Mad4Cakes
These Communion cupcakes from Mad4Cakes are a great alternative to a traditional cake — a simple cupcake and icing, topped with an icing plaque.
You can buy sugarpaste in most supermarkets. Roll it out thin, then use a cookie cutter (or even the rim of a glass) to make your topper. Add a cross, a flower, an initial, or just some glitter and decorations.
If you’d prefer something simpler, why not learn some new piping skills? This video shows how to create four types of stunning piped cupcakes with just one nozzle tip — perfect for beginners.
Communion Sheet Cake
Image: Willow Bird Baking
If you’re feeding a crowd, a rectangular sheet cake is a great option. Keep the decoration simple with white buttercream, and perhaps a few berries, fresh flowers or sprinkles.
Communion Dress Cupcakes
Image: Artrageous Desserts
Take a simple cupcake and turn it into something special. Shape your cupcakes into a replica of your daughter’s dress, then use a swirl icing effect to design a stunning Communion dress in cupcake form.
Cupcake Cross
Image: Artisan Bake Shop
Another easy option is a cross-shaped cupcake arrangement. Created the same way as the dress design above, the effect is best achieved with plenty of icing to fill any gaps between the cupcakes.
You May Also Enjoy 20 Alternative First Communion Gifts that are not Money
Stained Glass Cake
Image: Amy Leigh’s Cakes
This stained glass-effect cake looks impressive, but don’t be put off by the shape or the icing work — it’s entirely doable.
First, bake a rectangular cake, then use a sharp knife to cut curved edges at one end for the window shape. Make your buttercream icing and divide it into bowls, one for each colour you plan to use. Use a light colour (white or yellow work well) to pipe the outline of the stained glass panes, including a cross or any other design you like. Once the outline is in place, alternate colours and fill in the “stained glass”. The result is striking and completely unique.
You May Also Enjoy How to Throw a Stress-Free Communion Party at Home
Rose Cake
Image: I Am Baker
We did promise easy Communion cakes, and this is simply the piping skills from the cupcake video above taken up a level. These roses look amazing and are sure to deliver the wow factor. This particular cake is a white layer cake with a fudgy brownie base.
If you’d like a tutorial on piping roses onto a cake, this video walks through it step by step — if you’re feeling brave, you could even try the ombre look:
How to Make a Cross-Shaped Cake
A cross is the traditional shape for a Communion cake, but it can seem daunting for a novice decorator. You can recreate this look with white buttercream to cover the cake, then coloured icing for dots, patterns or edging if you wish.
Image: Cake Central
The best part is that you don’t need any special tins. You can make a cross cake easily from a large sheet cake: cut the sheet cake in half lengthways, then cut one half at the one-third mark. Join the pieces to form the cross shape, cover with buttercream, and decorate.
You May Also Enjoy How to Save Money on the True Cost of First Communion
Cake Bunting
If cake decorating really isn’t your thing, you can still make a special Communion cake for your child. Cake bunting is a lovely, low-skill option.
Image: Paper Jackdaw
All you need are toothpicks, wooden skewers or paper straws to hold the bunting, some fine string or twine, and your bunting flags. These could spell out your child’s name or colour-coordinate with the rest of your Communion decorations.
Looking For More?
Take some inspiration from these stunning First Communion hairstyles that range from simple and classic to wondrous up-dos!
Communion Cake Pops
Image: Show Me Love Confections
Cake pops are a fun, bite-size choice, and kids love them. The best part is that they can be made from crumbled cake if disaster strikes with your main bake!
These gorgeous pops are perfect for an easy Communion cake idea. If you’ve never made cake pops before, don’t worry — all you need is crumbled cake, some buttercream, lollipop sticks, cake melts or white chocolate, and sprinkles if desired. This video gives a useful step-by-step:
Frequently Asked Questions
What’s the easiest Communion cake to make at home?
A plain iced sheet cake or a batch of decorated cupcakes are the simplest options. Both need minimal equipment and forgive small imperfections better than a tall, tiered cake.
Do I need special equipment for Communion cake decorating?
No. Most of the designs above use things you likely already have or can pick up easily — a toothpick for outlining, shop-bought sugarpaste, a piping bag and a single nozzle tip, or a cookie cutter for icing toppers.
Can I make a cross-shaped cake without a special tin?
Yes. A cross shape can be cut from an ordinary rectangular sheet cake, then pieced together and covered in buttercream — no special tins required.
What if I’m not confident decorating at all?
Cake bunting or a simple cupcake topper are great no-decorating-skill options, and cake pops are a forgiving choice if a cake doesn’t come out as planned.
You Might Also Like
- 10 Inspirational Ideas for Homemade First Communion Cakes
- 30 Reasons to Know You’re the Mum to a First Communion Child
- How to Throw a Stress-Free Communion Party at Home
- How to Save Money on the True Cost of First Communion
- Stunning First Communion Hairstyles
Will you be creating one of our easy Communion cakes for your child this year? Leave a comment below and let us know — we’d love to hear from you!
Looking for more Communion inspiration? Browse our full collection of Communion ideas and save your favourites for when you start planning.
